Skip to guide content
My Favorite FindsIndependent product guide
All recommendations

jactimblin382's pick · Updated June 2026

BLACK+DECKER® 2-Slice Toaster with 7 Toast Shade Settings

BLACK+DECKER® 2-Slice Toaster with 7 Toast Shade Settings, Extra-Wide Slots for Bagels, Stainless Steel Exterior Finish
The pick

I keep this toaster on a small counter, and what I wanted from it was simple: I wanted breakfast to stop being fussy. That is really the type of person this is for, somebody who makes toast, bagels, English muffins, maybe the odd frozen waffle, and does not want to stand there babysitting a slot that heats unevenly or takes forever to decide it is done.

What I like most is that it does the basic job without turning it into a whole event. The shade settings give you enough control to get it where you want it, which matters more than people think. Too many toasters only give you the choice between pale and burnt. This one lets you land somewhere in the middle, and once you find your usual setting, you do not have to guess every morning. The wider slots are useful too. Bagels fit without having to shove them in sideways or press them down until the bread looks unhappy. That sounds minor, but it makes the toaster feel practical instead of annoying.

The stainless exterior also helps it feel a little more put together than the cheapest little toaster you grab just because it is there. It wipes down easily, which matters because crumbs and fingerprints show up fast on anything that sits near the stove. It does not take up much room, and that counts in my kitchen. I do not want every appliance to dominate the counter. I want it to earn its spot and stay out of the way.

If I am being honest, the one thing I would change is that the shade dial takes a little getting used to. Like most toasters, the numbers are only a rough guide until you figure out what your bread and your taste actually need. The first few tries are usually about learning the machine, not just pushing a button and walking off. That is not a dealbreaker, just the normal small adjustment that comes with any toaster worth keeping.

I also think people sometimes overcomplicate what a toaster needs to be. For me, this sits in the right place between bare-bones and overdone. It is not trying to be a smart appliance. It is not crowding the counter with extras I will never use. It toasts bread, handles bagels better than the narrow-slot versions, and looks decent doing it. That is enough.

I reach for this kind of toaster when I want breakfast to work without thinking about it. Toast comes out evenly enough that I do not end up flipping slices around or running them through again. A bagel gets warm and crisp without feeling like I fought the machine to get there. For a small household, or for somebody who just wants a reliable toaster that does not act precious, this is an easy one to live with.

If your kitchen routine is pretty ordinary and you want a toaster that matches that, this is a sensible choice. It does the job, it fits real bread, and it stays simple. That is usually what I want in a countertop appliance, and this one gets that part right.

Amazon product links on this guide are not currently affiliate links. Neither jactimblin382 nor Buyer Field Guide earns an affiliate commission from them.

See current price